Patent Trolls & Privateering

Although it is the mission of Cramer Patent & Design to keep their inventor client out of court, the so-called “Patent Trolls” are everywhere. In 2012, 56% of the patent lawsuits were directly linked to the Patent Trolls, also known in more polite circles as “Non-Practicing Entities.”
So what are Patent Trolls? They are similar to the ugly troll characters in children stories that live under bridges and threaten all who dare to cross. The equally ugly Patent Trolls are companies who own patents not to produce products, but strictly for the purpose of extorting money from companies that actually make and sell products.
The Patent Trolls buy patents from companies that are going out of business, or from companies that have decided not to pursue further product development. Instead of using the patents to make something worthwhile, they use the legal system to force dubious payment demands from productive companies. The practice is seen by many for what it really is – extortion.
The practice of trolling first reared its ugly head in the early 1990s. A famous 1994 industrial film entitled “The Patents Video” warned of trolls lurking in the mossy undergrowth looking for patent licensing revenue from their dubious claims. Later, at the turn of the millennium, a lawyer with the micro-chip maker Intel popularized the “Patent Troll” term. He was so frustrated with low merit patent infringement suits, totaling $15-billion, by companies that never attempted to bring a single microchip to market. The scheme was to make it less expensive for legitimate companies just to pay off the Trolls.
Another frustrating practice is “Patent Privateering.” This happens when a company arms a third-party Patent Troll with patent rights with the sole
purpose of bringing nuisance suits against a competitor. These patents are generally newer and hence more valuable to companies manufacturing
products from them. The Privateering scheme works like this: Company A gives a Patent Troll a book of patents after first taking a license for their exclusive use of the patents, then the Patent Troll goes after an honest competitor attempting to tie them up in court, extract money, and provide a business distraction. The current Smartphone war amongst Apple, Samsung, HTC, Nokia and Google is a perfect example.
It is sad to witness how patents that were always intended to protect the creative rights of inventors and to promote the creative spirit, are turning into weapons to be used in business. Patent Trolling and Privateering are not legitimate cases of inventors protecting their intellectual property rights; but rather, the unsavory practices of extortion and the slowing of innovation.
As always, the ultimate loser is you and me, the consumer. The consumer loses with higher product prices having the cost of litigation and payments to Trolls factored in. The consumer also loses with delays in product development as patent rights are litigated. On a positive note, many large companies are recently signing on to support legislation to stop Patent Trolls and Privateers.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Get Free Inventor Kit

Begin Your Invention Journey

By continuing, I’m providing consent to For Sale By Inventor to contact me at the phone number and email provided. Contact may be by phone, email, text or prerecorded message. I understand that my proceeding is considered an electronic signature only, which I may revoke at any time and does not require me to purchase services.


  • Full Service Agency for Inventors
  • Free Consultation. 100% Safe.
  • Avoid Common Inventor Mistakes.

Updating…
loading spinner

Official Record of Invention Form

Statement Of Non-Disclosure and Complete Confidentiality Complete this form for a free, no obligation review of your idea.

This Record of Invention Form certifies that you are the originator of the invention disclosed, including all additional information submitted moving forward from this date. This Non-Disclosure Agreement certifies that nobody within or associated with For Sale By Inventor may knowingly manufacture, sell, distribute or attempt to profit from your invention in any way from the date you submit your invention.

The information you submit may be shared with a separate patent law firm to evaluate patentability and intellectual property rights. The information shared with a separate patent law firm will be bound by attorney client privilege.

All employees and representatives of For Sale By Inventor, including all related companies within the Montgomery IP Associates family of companies, are required to sign confidentiality agreements to ensure complete confidence for you and your invention idea.

*A digitally time-dated copy of your Record of Invention will be sent to you by email immediately upon submission for your records.

Disclosure

Your ideas are safe.

The purpose of the Inventor Disclosure is to inform inventors that the process of creating a new product/concept and developing it into a commercial success is extremely difficult, time consuming, often frustrating, confusing and usually costly. To succeed, inventors normally must accomplish, at a high level: the legal process (patents, copyrights, trademarks, etc); engineering, scientific or technical factors; production concerns; and, market distribution. For an individual inventor, this can be a daunting task and should be carefully considered before risking talents, time, energies and capital.

Although an inventor can always represent themselves, inventors are strongly encouraged to seek advice and assistance only from licensed professionals. For Sale By Inventor’s mission is to provide coordinated, professional services for inventors to help launch their invention ideas into new products onto the market.

For Sale By Inventor specializes in consulting, researching and educating small and micro entity inventors. For Sale By Inventor never evaluates an invention in terms of potential marketability.

For Sale By Inventor refers all patent and engineering work to a separate patent law firm on behalf of inventor clients. Advertising, virtual prototypes, websites and representation services are provided by Advertising – Generation, LLC through their proprietary website ForSaleByInventor.com. This process ensures a coordinated effort and complete confidentiality.

For Sale By Inventor and any related entities neither singularly nor collectively, considers itself to be an invention promoter or developer; regardless, the following is disclosed in the spirit of full disclosure.

The total number of inventors who contacted For Sale By Inventor and any related entities over the past 5 years is approximately 125,000; from that total, approximately 60,000 submitted ideas for review with about 12,000 offered contracts for research services; resulting in 3,974 contracting for professional research services. Following research, 2,162 received positive professional opinions of patentability and feasibility and were proffered development agreements. 1,127 inventors contracted for some combination of our patent, engineering and marketing services.

Of the total clients contracting for our services, 53 received licensing agreements and 27 have reported a net financial profit while hundreds of cases still remain active. Licensing is just one option that an inventor can pursue to commercialize their invention and was not pursued by clients who only contracted for legal, engineering or sales representation services. An additional 182 inventions have reported commercial success meaning that they either have been or are currently available for sale. Since these clients have no obligation to report their specific financial records to us, we are not aware of how many of these have made more than they spent on their invention.

DISCLAIMER: Past performance of professional services can provide no guarantee of future profits or that anyone will agree to purchase, license, produce or distribute any invention idea. Bringing an invention from an idea to marketed product is a high risk venture.

rev. 7/2017

By providing us with your information you are consenting to the collection and use of your information in accordance with our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Customer Reviews

Most Popular Posts

Blog Categories

Wishlist 0
Continue Shopping